| Year | Category | Actor | Show |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1980 | Best Actress | Susan Frick | 6 Rms Riv Vu |
| Best Actor | Jim Gilmour | 6 Rms Riv Vu | |
| Best Supporting Actress | Marcia Roberts | A Majority of One | |
| Best Supporting Actor | Ron Crick | A Majority of One | |
| Backstage Award | Suzy Brooks | Makeup | |
| Backstage Award | Marie Rennick | Costumes | |
| Backstage Award | Becky Shafer | Publicity Art | |
| Jean Lewis Scholarship | Frank Rose | ||
| 1981 | Best Actress | Tobi L. Baer | Born Yesterday |
| Best Actor | Jim Knoblauch | One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest | |
| Best Supporting Actress | Nancy Nichols | Bell, Book, and Candle | |
| Best Supporting Actor | Fred Legg | One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest | |
| Backstage Award | Jeannette Dumais | Props and Furnishings | |
| Meritorious Service Award | Max Sperling | Membership Sales | |
| Meritorious Service Award | Jean Lewis | 20 years of Children’s Theater | |
| Jean Lewis Scholarship | Carol Davis | ||
| 1982 | Best Actress | Barbara McKinzie | Tribute |
| Best Actor | Bob Tolliver | Tribute | |
| Best Supporting Actress | Sue Ann Crick | Tribute | |
| Best Supporting Actress | Patty Ferris | Chapter Two | |
| Best Supporting Actor | Jim Gilmour | Chapter Two | |
| Building Manager Award | Leon Ewbank | ||
| Backstage Award | Alfreda Klingensmith | ||
| Jean Lewis Scholarship | Jamie Briggs | ||
Accepted the Del Purkey Memorial | Gretchen Purkey | ||
| 1983 | Best Actress | Barbara Stover | On Golden Pond |
| Best Actor | Fred Legg | On Golden Pond | |
| Best Supporting Actress | Nancy Nichols | Deathtrap | |
| Best Supporting Actor | Bill Brandy | On Golden Pond | |
| Backstage Award | Benn Darner | Publicity | |
| Jean Lewis Scholarship | Robyn Briggs | ||
| 1984 | Best Actress | Susan Frick | Same Time, Next Year |
| Best Actor | David E. Laker | The Paisley Convertible | |
| Best Supporting Actress | Lura S. Boggs | The Paisley Convertible | |
| Best Supporting Actor | J. Scott Eisenhauer | The Paisley Convertible | |
| Backstage Award | Brad Smith | Sets | |
| Meritorious Service Award | Susan Frick | ||
| Jean Lewis Scholarship | Judd Caraker | ||
| 1985 | Best Actress | Nancy Nichols | Sly Fox |
| Best Actress | Mary Brandt | The Second Time Around | |
| Best Actor | Bill Brandy | Sly Fox | |
| Best Supporting Actress | Marty Howrey | The Second Time Around | |
| Best Supporting Actor | Tony Fiaschetti | The Second Time Around | |
| Backstage Award | Gail West | ||
| Jean Lewis Scholarship | Anne E. Boggs | ||
| 1986 | Best Actress | Marty Howrey | The Gingerbread Lady |
| Best Actor | Edward Sant | The Gingerbread Lady | |
| Best Supporting Actress | Lisa Gilmour | Bus Stop | |
| Best Supporting Actor | Jim Stuart | Bus Stop | |
| Meritorious Service Award | Meritorious Service Award | Box Office | |
| Jean Lewis Scholarship | Jean Lewis Scholarship | ||
| 1987 | Best Actress | Marty Howrey | You Can't Take It With You |
| Best Actress | Debby Vinyard | Night of January 16th | |
| Best Actor | Fred Legg | Cactus Flower | |
| Best Supporting Actress | Pat Simpson | Night of January 16th | |
| Best Supporting Actor | Jon Aschermann | Night of January 16th | |
| Meritorious Service Award | Liz Miller | 50th Anniversary | |
| Meritorious Service Award | Jean Lewis | 25 Years of Children's Theatre | |
| 50th Anniversary Award | Sue Ann Crick | ||
| 50th Anniversary Award | Susan Frick | ||
| Amalgamated Unicorn Award | Liz Miller | ||
| Amalgamated Unicorn Award | Barbara Vinson | ||
| Amalgamated Unicorn Award | Susan Frick | ||
| Jean Lewis Scholarship | Timothy Estep | ||
| 1988 | Best Actress | Pat Simpson | I Never Sang for My Father |
| Best Actor | Fred Legg | I Never Sang for My Father | |
| Best Supporting Actress | Marty Howrey | I Never Sang for My Father | |
| Best Supporting Actor | Darrin Deck | Norman, Is That You? | |
| Meritorious Service Award | Barry Boyd Photography | ||
| Meritorious Service Award | Carter's Furniture | ||
| Jean Lewis Scholarship | Jennifer Lewsader | ||
| 1989 | Best Actress | Sue Ann Crick | The Odd Couple |
| Best Actor | John Dowers | The Importance of Being Earnest | |
| Best Supporting Actress | Pam Ray | To Gillian on Her 37th Birthday | |
| Best Supporting Actror | Terry Walters | To Gillian on Her 37th Birthday | |
| Meritorious Service Award | Bess Castle | ||
| Jean Lewis Scholarship | Jennifer Lewsader | ||