| Year | Category | Actor | Show |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1955 | Best Actress | Honore Ronan | The Glass Menagerie |
| Best Actor | B.J. Smith | The Glass Menagerie | |
| 1956 | Best Actress | Shirley Sharpf | Dial M For Murder |
| Best Actor | Bill Buchar | Dial M For Murder | |
| 1957 | Best Actress | Katherine Gerrard | The Silver Cord |
| Best Actor | R. Cameron Snyder | The Desperate Hours | |
| 1958 | Best Actress | Charlotte Ellis Gillis | Affairs of State |
| Best Actor | Bob Wright | Affairs of State | |
| 1959 | Best Actress | Jean Henson Acton | Sabrina Fair |
| Best Actor | Bud Ehrlich | The Fifth Season |